-----
Dead Silence is the 16th "Doc Ford" novel by Randy Wayne White. Ford is a marine biologist who also happens to be a sometimes-retired secret agent. He lives in South Florida and consults with a number of clients in both of his fields of expertise. Several oddball characters populate the area and circulate in and out of the Doc Ford novels, including his hippie stoner pal with a mysterious past, Tomlinson. That past plays a role in Dead Silence. While visiting a lady friend who happens to be a U.S. Senator, Ford foils an attempt to kidnap her. Unfortunately, the kidnappers get the teenage essay contest winner who the Senator was showing around New York City on his prize tour, and she enslists Doc's aid to find the boy before time runs out. Although the series has a big following and Doc's had some entertaining adventures, Dead Silence is a big sprawling mess, mashed together like a series of writing exercises someone's tried to craft into a novel using tacked-on transitions. The story hangs on a baker's dozen of coincidences, each individually less plausible than a royal flush deal from Doc Holliday. Together they add up to a tale even more unlikely than surviving a negative performance review from Darth Vader. As sauce, White throws in a couple of ugly -- and in one case, completely irrelevant -- murders.
-----
With Brimstone, Robert B. Parker supposedly brings to a close his trilogy featuring Old West lawmen Virgil Cole and Everett Hitch. In Appaloosa and Resolution, detective novelist Parker found a new vein of creativity and energy that his other series of books had begun to sorely lack. Time will tell if Parker decides to continue Cole and Hitch as a series; he had originally planned for Appaloosa as a stand-alone, but fan response brought forth the other two books. In Brimstone, Cole and Hitch find themselves in a town of that name, having found Cole's wandering lady-love, Allie French. They hire on as deputies and see that trouble may be in the offing between saloon owner Pike and town preacher Brother Percival. Allie has begun to attend services at Brother Percival's church, but Cole and Hitch must find a way to keep the law and play no favorites. Brimstone is a fun enough read for a Western fan but is also easily the weakest of the three Cole-Hitch books. That Percival is up to no good is obvious from the get-go. The evil clergyman is a lazy trick for any novelist and it's especially so for Parker; in 36 Spenser novels, eight Jesse Stone novels, six Sunny Randall novels and a dozen others, Parker has had probably one honest, straight-dealing religious character (a nun who works with runaways in 2002's Jesse Stone entry, Death in Paradise). Brimstone stands head, shoulders and Stetson above anything Parker's modern characters have done in the last several years, but this kind of shoddy shortcut makes me hope he either really is finished with Cole and Hitch or he can manage to match future volumes to Appaloosa's level.
No comments:
Post a Comment