Mike Lupica's success at reviving Robert B. Parker's Sunny Randall
series led the late author's estate and publisher to hand him the Jesse
Stone novels once Reed Farrell Coleman's turn was finished. Lupica had
shown himself better able to move in Parker's world, in addition to
being a better mimic of Parker's style.
Lupica also returned
Jesse to a previous flirtation with Sunny and established them in a
relationship of a sort, building on the developments he'd made in his
Randall novels. Robert B. Parker himself was rather tediously enamored
with relationships in which the principals couldn't be together but
couldn't be apart either, and he often wasted a lot of pages on that
kind of dance during his novels from the mid-90s forward. Despite a
number of straight-up duds, Coleman had added the welcome wrinkle of
making Jesse sober, and Lupica continued it.
A land deal in
Paradise could mean a lot of money with a casino development, but
there's also strong opposition. The mayor counts himself as one of the
opposed, but he doesn't have many levers to pull to thwart the
third-party sale of the land. Nevertheless, he's thrown every block he
can and delayed things long enough so that when he's found dead Jesse
has no shortage of suspects. Add in the environmentalist group that may
be willing to take extreme measures and the ongoing dissolution of the
mayor's marriage, and about the only thing Jesse is sure of in
Stone's Throw is that he and his department didn't do it.
Fool's Paradise was a promising debut for Lupica, but
Throw unfortunately revives several
other
things from Parker's own time with Stone that were better left in the
past. One is to send Jesse and Sunny back through the relationship spin
cycle, this time because she has a relationship she's not sure is as
over as she thought it was. As mentioned above, Parker wore this path
smooth and here it brings nothing to the story.
Another major
blunder is the return of the Native American mob enforcer Wilson
Cromartie, or Crow. Parker created the character for 1999's
Trouble in Paradise as a part of a heist crew in a weak TV-movie-level story and brought him back in 2008's
Stranger in Paradise,
an even weaker entry. Jesse's dependable assistant chief Molly Crane
inexplicably had a one-night stand with Crow in this second book and
Lupica dawdles around with both of them in a couple of viewpoint
sequences where they reflect on that time -- Crow wondering what made
him desire Molly and Molly wondering whether she can resist a second
tryst.
Add these meanderings to a sloppily-built and confusing
story -- was this attack made by the first pair of cardboard-cutout
thugs or the second one, and what's the point anyway -- and
Stone's Throw calls back more to Parker's later and lesser Stone outings than his
earlier ones. It's definitely a move away from Coleman's wordy and often
fumbling grasp of Paradise and its people, but not necessarily in the
right direction.